In Journal of magnetic resonance imaging : JMRI
BACKGROUND : Recently, deep learning via convolutional neural networks (CNNs) has largely superseded conventional methods for proton (1 H)-MRI lung segmentation. However, previous deep learning studies have utilized single-center data and limited acquisition parameters.
PURPOSE : Develop a generalizable CNN for lung segmentation in 1 H-MRI, robust to pathology, acquisition protocol, vendor, and center.
STUDY TYPE : Retrospective.
POPULATION : A total of 809 1 H-MRI scans from 258 participants with various pulmonary pathologies (median age (range): 57 (6-85); 42% females) and 31 healthy participants (median age (range): 34 (23-76); 34% females) that were split into training (593 scans (74%); 157 participants (55%)), testing (50 scans (6%); 50 participants (17%)) and external validation (164 scans (20%); 82 participants (28%)) sets.
FIELD STRENGTH/SEQUENCE : 1.5-T and 3-T/3D spoiled-gradient recalled and ultrashort echo-time 1 H-MRI.
ASSESSMENT : 2D and 3D CNNs, trained on single-center, multi-sequence data, and the conventional spatial fuzzy c-means (SFCM) method were compared to manually delineated expert segmentations. Each method was validated on external data originating from several centers. Dice similarity coefficient (DSC), average boundary Hausdorff distance (Average HD), and relative error (XOR) metrics to assess segmentation performance.
STATISTICAL TESTS : Kruskal-Wallis tests assessed significances of differences between acquisitions in the testing set. Friedman tests with post hoc multiple comparisons assessed differences between the 2D CNN, 3D CNN, and SFCM. Bland-Altman analyses assessed agreement with manually derived lung volumes. A P value of <0.05 was considered statistically significant.
RESULTS : The 3D CNN significantly outperformed its 2D analog and SFCM, yielding a median (range) DSC of 0.961 (0.880-0.987), Average HD of 1.63 mm (0.65-5.45) and XOR of 0.079 (0.025-0.240) on the testing set and a DSC of 0.973 (0.866-0.987), Average HD of 1.11 mm (0.47-8.13) and XOR of 0.054 (0.026-0.255) on external validation data.
DATA CONCLUSION : The 3D CNN generated accurate 1 H-MRI lung segmentations on a heterogenous dataset, demonstrating robustness to disease pathology, sequence, vendor, and center.
EVIDENCE LEVEL : 4.
TECHNICAL EFFICACY : Stage 1.
Astley Joshua R, Biancardi Alberto M, Hughes Paul J C, Marshall Helen, Collier Guilhem J, Chan Ho-Fung, Saunders Laura C, Smith Laurie J, Brook Martin L, Thompson Roger, Rowland-Jones Sarah, Skeoch Sarah, Bianchi Stephen M, Hatton Matthew Q, Rahman Najib M, Ho Ling-Pei, Brightling Chris E, Wain Louise V, Singapuri Amisha, Evans Rachael A, Moss Alastair J, McCann Gerry P, Neubauer Stefan, Raman Betty, Wild Jim M, Tahir Bilal A
2023-Feb-17
CNN, deep learning, lung, segmentation
