In The Journal of arthroplasty ; h5-index 65.0
BACKGROUND : It is well-documented in the orthopedic literature that 1 in 5 patients are dissatisfied following total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, multiple statistical models have failed to explain the causes of dissatisfaction. Furthermore, payers are interested in using patient-reported satisfaction scores to adjust surgeon reimbursement rates without a full understanding of the influencing parameters. The purpose of this study was to more comprehensively identify predictors of satisfaction and compare results using both a statistical model and a machine learning (ML) algorithm.
METHODS : A retrospective review of consecutive TKAs performed by 2 surgeons was conducted. Identical perioperative protocols were utilized by both surgeons. Patients were grouped as satisfied or unsatisfied based on self-reported satisfaction scores. Fifteen variables were correlated with satisfaction using binary logistic regression and stochastic gradient boosted ML models.
RESULTS : In total, 1325 consecutive TKAs were performed. After exclusions, 897 TKAs were available with minimum 1-year follow-up. Overall, 85.3% of patients were satisfied. Older age generation and performing surgeon were predictors of satisfaction in both models. The ML model also retained cruciate-retaining/condylar-stabilizing implant; lack of inflammatory conditions, preoperative narcotic use, depression, and lumbar spine pain; female gender; and a preserved posterior cruciate ligament as predictors of satisfaction which allowed for a significantly higher area under the receiver operator characteristic curve compared to the binary logistic regression model (0.81 vs 0.60).
CONCLUSION : Findings indicate that patient satisfaction may be multifactorial with some factors beyond the scope of a surgeon's control. Further study is warranted to investigate predictors of patient satisfaction particularly with awareness of differences in results between traditional statistical models and ML algorithms.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE : Therapeutic Level III.
Farooq Hassan, Deckard Evan R, Ziemba-Davis Mary, Madsen Adam, Meneghini R Michael
binary logistic regression, machine learning, predictors, satisfaction, total knee arthroplasty